Hi BJ,
Nice to read your message! I did a lot of research, and what I found out is that it's possible to put American non-Spanish speaking kids/teens in school in Mexico, but not super easy. Here are the drawbacks I read about:
- The International schools can be quite expensive, especially in Cancun/Cozumel which seems to attract wealthy Americans.
- The Mexican kids who also attend the International schools (and often make up around 80% of the student body) tend to be of the rich/upper class variety, and there can be considerable snobbishness towards poorer people, including their teachers, and towards American students for being different and less class-oriented.
- The public schools are taught almost entirely in Spanish and are not a good option for older kids who can't learn language as quickly and who would thus have to take difficult courses in a foreign language.
That said, the schools in the Cancun/Cozumel area did seem the most appealing to me. I think they would offer more of what Americans are looking for overall. Another option I found was homeschooling. There are a number of programs that allow kids to do high school work from a laptop, even connecting with online classrooms, and then fly back to the US twice per school year for final exams.
In our case, we decided to stick it out here in the US for the next three years. I just couldn't find a way to make it work easily, and I started to think about what my son would be doing after high school. Going to a US university with a high school degree from an International School in Mexico is do-able for sure, but then why are we moving there now, if he needs to come right back here for college? And if we stayed there, what type of college or work opportunities would he have in Mexico? I realized I was making a very big decision for him too, and I decided it makes more sense to just finish out his education here and then he can make these decisions for himself as an adult. As for me, I will probably start living part-time in Mexico eventually. Both my kids are older and I will have more flexibility soon.
Good luck with your search, it's definitely complicated, but not impossible!