taxes

Court ruling prevents UK tax man from seeking certain information from expats

by Ray Clancy on January 12, 2018

A landmark ruling in the British High Court means that the taxman cannot pursue expats who have moved abroad permanently to countries that do not have a reciprocal tax agreement with the UK.

It comes after expat Michael Jimenez, who used to be a co-owner of Charlton Athletic Football Club, challenged HMRC over the issuing of a Schedule 36 notice demanding tax information some 10 years after he had moved abroad.

(onephoto/Bigstock.com)

The High Court has ruled that HMRC cannot chase expats overseas for such information, effectively paving the way for expats to ignore enquiries made through this route if they live in a location where there is no reciprocal tax agreement.

Jimenez left the UK in 2002, lived in Cyprus and then in Dubai. When HMRC sought information he pointed out that he had been living away from the UK for a decade having cut all ties with the country.

HMRC then issued a Schedule 36 notice to him at his home in Dubai demanding information but he challenged their right to do so. The court was tasked with deciding how much power HMRC has outside of the UK. As a general rule, countries will not assist other countries to collect tax unless they have a reciprocal arrangement.
It was argued by HMRC that Jimenez was a taxpayer for the purposes of Schedule 36 and it did have the power to give a notice to such taxpayers outside the UK to help establish that taxpayer’s tax position.

In court Mr Justice Charles agreed that HMRC’s approach was both unlawful and unreasonable and that Schedule 36 does not provide a power to give the taxpayer notice that was given to Jimenez in Dubai.

Mr Justice Charles made it clear that the British tax authorities were only empowered to make demands of non-UK resident citizens if a reciprocal tax-related agreement was in place between the UK and the expat’s present country of residence.

Independent Tax, which specialises in HMRC disputes, said that the firm has seen many instances of HMRC issuing Schedule 36 notices to taxpayers outside the UK and the judicial review should end that practice.
‘The judgment recognises that HMRC already has a viable and lawful route through the international tax enforcement arrangements protocol to seek information or documents held outside the UK,’ said a spokesman.
He added that the ruling applies to outstanding Schedule 36 demand and there may be recourse for expats who have complied with the notices in the past as the judgement can only be overturned by the Court of Appeal.

Jimenez hopes it will help other expats. ‘For a long time HMRC have held the view that distance was no object to their powers meaning any expats outside of the UK were in their sights long after they had left the UK. Young or old, rich or poor, retired or not or simply wanting to move to warmer climates and having made the decision to no longer be a resident of the UK, made no difference the attitude that HMRC adopted towards these e-pats. This ruling shows that this is fundamentally not the case and that HMRC’s powers actually stop at the UK border,’ he said.

{ 0 comments }

Thumbnail image for British expats renting out a property in UK facing tax crackdown

British expats renting out a property in UK facing tax crackdown

January 1, 2018 United Kingdom

British expats who own property in the UK and rent it out face a crackdown from the taxman to make sure they are paying the right amount of tax on their business. HMRC has revealed plans that would make it compulsory for a landlord applying for a licence for houses in multiple occupation, often known […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Wealth tax and parking fines top the list of changes for people in France in 2018

Wealth tax and parking fines top the list of changes for people in France in 2018

December 28, 2017 France

As is usual, a number of changes that affect people living in France will be brought in by the Government on the first of January 2018, some of which will have implications for expats. Perhaps the biggest change is a change to the notorious wealth tax. Under reforms promised by French President Emmanuel Macron. The […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Trump’s tax changes could benefit US expats in the UK

Trump’s tax changes could benefit US expats in the UK

June 9, 2017 America

While many expats from Europe may be considering leaving the UK due to Brexit, Americans could be set to find living in Britain is more tax effective. London already has a large number of wealthier American expats and tax plans by US President Donald Trump is set to end the practice of having to pay […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for American expats flocking to declare foreign assets amid fear of Trump crackdown

American expats flocking to declare foreign assets amid fear of Trump crackdown

April 14, 2017 America

American expats are concerned that the recently elected President Donald Trump could put an end to a more lenient attitude to tax owed. Under previous President Barack Obama there was a generous amnesty for American expats who had not previously declared their foreign assets to the US tax authorities. But now research suggests that Americans […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Trump and taxes pushing Americans to move abroad and renounce citizenship

Trump and taxes pushing Americans to move abroad and renounce citizenship

January 29, 2017 America

The new American President Donald Trump has been ruffling feathers during his first few days in office and there have been concerns that his policies could lead to more Americans deciding to move abroad. But it will be what Trump does with taxes that could be the deciding factors for potential expats, many of whom […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Workers in France and Belgium are the most taxed in Europe

Workers in France and Belgium are the most taxed in Europe

September 12, 2016 France

Expats looking for a more liberal tax regime might want to avoid France and Belgium which a study have found are the most taxed countries in Europe. The annual study by think tank the Molinari Institute, which works out a tax freedom day for each country which is the date when the tax man is […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Call for UK citizens to pay tax on their global income to HMRC

Call for UK citizens to pay tax on their global income to HMRC

July 19, 2016 United Kingdom

UK citizens should pay taxes to the British taxman on their global income regardless of where they live in the world which would make the system simpler, according to a new report. Currently tax is collected by HMRC in the UK on the basis of residency, but according to the Chartered Institute for Securities and […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for More people moving to South Florida than ever before

More people moving to South Florida than ever before

June 6, 2016 America

South Florida is attracting expats from around the world, many of whom buy a holiday home and then end up moving there, an international conference has heard. Of the 500,000 new residents who moved to the Miami, Broward, Palm Beach metro area over the last five years, for example, some 65% or 335,000, came from […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for British expats already feeling stressed over future of EU membership

British expats already feeling stressed over future of EU membership

March 30, 2016 Britain

Treaties would need to be put in place to recreate the current situation when it comes to tax, pensions, study and properties if the UK votes to leave the European Union in the upcoming referendum in June. There have been a variety of claims about what this would mean for British expats in Europe with […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for New report gives insight into tax costs for expats investing in real estate

New report gives insight into tax costs for expats investing in real estate

March 29, 2016 property

Expats investing in property around the world need to consider real estate taxes as well as currency exchange and the shifting fiscal environment, according to a new report. It analyses the costs for foreign individuals buying a property in 15 key cities around the world as well as the holding and selling costs over a […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Record number of US expats renouncing their citizenship, with tax system to blame

Record number of US expats renouncing their citizenship, with tax system to blame

February 11, 2016 America

Evidence is mounting that more US citizens are giving up their nationality because of an addition to the country’s tax system which means expats are being refused bank accounts. Figures from the US Treasury show that a record 4,279 people gave up their US citizenship or long term residency in 2015, an increase of 20% […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for The US Internal Revenue Service is failing expats, says new report

The US Internal Revenue Service is failing expats, says new report

January 14, 2016 America

The US tax man is failing to provide an adequate service for American taxpayers living abroad having closed overseas offices and reduced other services, according to a new report. Indeed, the report from the National Taxpayer Advocate, goes on to say that the US Internal Revenue Service (IRS) “does not sufficiently address the unique needs […]

Read the full article →