net migration

Call for simpler immigration system in the UK that takes needs into account

by Ray Clancy on January 16, 2018

The net migration target used in the UK to determine the numbers allowed to work in the country should be replaced by simpler and clearer immigration rules and take into account different kinds of immigration.

The current system is not working, according to the Parliamentary Home Affairs Committee, which is also calling for international students to be removed from the annual figures and no national target for those wishing to study in the UK.

Union Jack


It also calls for a greater focus on early enforcement, clearer criminal and security checks, and improved Home Office performance to tackle errors and delays and reassure the public that the system is both fair and under control.

It points out that there is clear public support for the continued arrival of high skilled, not just highly paid, workers who are needed in the economy. Immigration rules should allow UK businesses and organisations easily to attract top talent, with restrictions and controls focused more on low skilled migration.

It also suggests that immigration plans should be linked with training plans to increase domestic skills in sectors and regions where there are skills gaps that need to be filled through migration.

Immigration emerged as a major issue during the referendum on leaving the European Union but the report says that there is a considerable public appetite for engagement on the issue and much common ground on which to take the debate on what should happen post Brexit.

However, people need to be involved and achieving a national consensus on immigration will require the current approach to be transformed, the report says, adding that the current policy to reduce annual numbers to tens of thousands does not reflect what the public thinks or take into account that there are different kinds of immigration.

The report suggests that targets and controls on immigration should be set out in a newly established Annual Migration Report laid before and debated in Parliament modelled on that used in Canada.

The annual report would also detail the previous year’s migration flows, the economic contribution from migration to the Exchequer, consideration of the requirements for different regions and nations and measures taken by the Government to promote integration, manage impacts, costs and pressures.

It would also set out a three year plan for migration which would be reviewed annually and include public consultation at local and regional level. It would include parallel training plans to tackle skills shortages which are increasing demand for overseas workers and measures to tackle exploitation of low skilled migration.

Chair of the Home Affairs Committee, Yvette Cooper MP, called for a more open debate on immigration. ‘The Government has a responsibility to build consensus and confidence on immigration rather than allowing this to be a divisive debate. But that requires a transformation in the way that immigration policy is made as too often the current approach has undermined trust in the system,’ she said.

‘What’s striking is that there is considerable common ground in contrast to the polarisation we too often hear in national debates. The net migration target isn’t working to build confidence and it treats all migration as the same. That’s why it should be replaced by a different framework of targets and controls. And frankly the system needs to work effectively. As long as there are so many errors and so many problems with enforcement, people won’t have confidence that the system is either fair or robust,’ she pointed out.

‘Most people think immigration is important for Britain, but they want to know that the system is under control, that people are contributing to this country and that communities and public services are benefiting rather than facing pressures,’ she pointed out.

‘Immigration has always been an important part of our history, economy and culture and will continue to be a crucial policy area for our future. We cannot stress enough how important it is to prevent escalating divisions, polarisation, anger or misinformation on an issue like immigration. To fail to respond risks doing long term damage to the social fabric, economy and politics of our country,’ she added.


Thumbnail image for New Zealand still proving popular with expats from India and China in particular

New Zealand still proving popular with expats from India and China in particular

May 25, 2016 China

New Zealand is continuing to experience a boom in immigration but experts believe that the growth in numbers arriving from abroad is starting to slow. Official seasonally adjusted figures showed a net gain, that is more arrivals than departures, of 5,500 migrants in April 2016 with monthly gains steady and annual growth continuing. Indeed, the […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Migration to New Zealand remains steady, latest data shows

Migration to New Zealand remains steady, latest data shows

March 31, 2016 Australia

Newcomer numbers arriving in New Zealand have remained steady at the start of 2016 with the latest data showing there was a net gain of 6,100 migrants in February, unchanged from January. The figures from Statistics New Zealand also show that monthly net migration has remained relatively steady, fluctuating around the 6,000 mark since October […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Record low number of New Zealanders moving to Australia

Record low number of New Zealanders moving to Australia

May 22, 2014 Australia

Kiwi expats in Australian have always been a strong group, but figures now show that a record low number are moving to Australia. It is easier, in terms of visa requirements, for New Zealanders to live and work in Australia and the sheer numbers of those choosing to do so over recent decades has caused […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Fewer people dream of moving abroad permanently, new poll reveals

Fewer people dream of moving abroad permanently, new poll reveals

April 2, 2014 America

People’s desire globally to migrate permanently to other countries has cooled to 13%, but populations are still growing in Europe, the Middle East and North America, a new poll shows. The latest Potential Net Migration Index (PNMI) from Gallup shows populations would still grow in these areas if everyone who wanted to move actually moved […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Net migration increases in UK as fewer people move abroad

Net migration increases in UK as fewer people move abroad

June 3, 2011 Britain

The UK government face an uphill task to reduce the level of immigration by tens of thousands as the latest figures from the Office for National Statistics show that net migration has risen to its highest level in five years. A sharp fall in the number of people going to live abroad and a resurgence […]

Read the full article →