eu

EU judgement protects the rights of self-employed workers

by Ray Clancy on January 25, 2018

European citizens who are self-employed in another European Union state and become unemployed can continue to have the right to live in the country, a court has ruled.

The Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled in favour of a plaster from Romania who had been working in Ireland. He was self-employed from 2008 to 2012 and then applied for jobseeker’s allowance when work dried up due to the economic downturn.

(Matej Kastelic/Shutterstock.com)

The ruling could have implications for self-employed expats in the UK and British expats in EU countries regarding their status after Brexit. Negotiations point to a freezing of rights at a certain specified date. The judgment might affect, and indeed protect, a significant number of self-employed EU citizens who have worked for more than a year at that date but have ceased their economic activity.

The court heard that Florea Gusa worked as a self-employed plasterer and paid his taxes, pay related social insurance and other levies on his income in Ireland but in 2012 he stopped working, claiming an absence of work caused by the economic downturn.

Left without an income he registered as a jobseeker and applied for a jobseeker’s allowance in November 2014 but was refused on the ground that he had not demonstrated that he still had a right to reside in Ireland. It was considered that, on cessation of his self-employment as a plasterer, Gusa had lost the status of self-employed person and therefore no longer satisfied the conditions for a right of residence laid down by the Free Movement Directive.

Article 7 of the directive provides, however, that an EU citizen who is no longer a worker or self-employed person is to retain the status of worker or self-employed person, and thus a right of residence in the host Member State, in four cases. One of those cases is the situation in which a citizen ‘is in involuntary unemployment after having been employed for more than one year’.

Gusa argued that he has retained the status of self-employed person and, therefore, a right of residence in Ireland under that provision. The Irish authorities claimed, however, that provision applies only to persons who have worked as employees.

The judgement found that it cannot be inferred from the wording of the provision at issue that that provision covers only the situation of persons who have ceased to work as employed persons and excludes those who have ceased to work as self-employed persons.

The Court pointed out that there are variations between the different language versions of the directive. Certain versions refer, in essence, to work as an employee, whereas in others the EU legislature uses the neutral formulation of ‘occupational activity’ instead. But it also pointed out that where there is divergence between the various language versions of an act, the provision in question must be interpreted by reference to the general scheme and the purpose of the act.

The Court decided that while the directive distinguishes between the situation of economically active citizens from that of inactive citizens and students, it does not make a distinction between citizens working as employed persons and those working as self-employed persons in the host Member State.

{ 0 comments }

Thumbnail image for Think tank reveals impact of a post-Brexit transitional period for immigration

Think tank reveals impact of a post-Brexit transitional period for immigration

January 23, 2018 European Union

A British think tank is urging the government to reject the European Union’s demand to automatically allow European to have the chance to gain permanent settlement in the UK during a transition period. According to think tank Migration Watch UK, the number of EU nationals arriving in the course of a two year post-Brexit transition […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Brexit already having an impact on number of EU nationals moving to the UK

Brexit already having an impact on number of EU nationals moving to the UK

December 4, 2017 United Kingdom

One of the main reasons that people in Britain voted to leave the European Union was to have more control over immigration and official figures show that Brexit already seems to have had an impact. Fewer people are moving to the UK with the data from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) revealing that net […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Macron turns against the idea of total freedom of movement in the EU

Macron turns against the idea of total freedom of movement in the EU

August 31, 2017 European Union

While there has been much attention on how Brexit is going to affect people from the European Union moving to work in the UK, there are signs that France is also ready to crack down on workers. Recently elected French President Emmanuel Macron has indicated that he might support an EU deal to clamp down […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Age of anxiety detected in key European Union countries

Age of anxiety detected in key European Union countries

April 18, 2017 General

People in parts of Europe are becoming more pessimistic with research highlighting a growing trend in the UK, France, Germany, Spain, Poland and Sweden of widespread gloom and anxiety. The pan-European study found low levels of trust in both European Union and national political institutions and less support for cultural and ethnic diversity at a […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for UK pensions changes set to affect British expats

UK pensions changes set to affect British expats

December 13, 2016 Britain

British expats who are concerned about their pension investments when the UK leaves the European Union need to be aware of new changes announced by the Government, particularly if they are planning to move back. UK Chancellor Philip Hammond has confirmed that Qualifying Recognised Overseas Pension Schemes’ (QROPS) tax rules will become more closely aligned […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for EU citizens want to stay in the UK after Brexit

EU citizens want to stay in the UK after Brexit

December 5, 2016 Britain

Brexit has created a time of uncertainty for expats across Europe and it would seem that most want to stay where they are and are willing to change their status to do so. In the UK there are millions of citizens from other European Union countries who have been working and living in the country […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for UK Immigration Taskforce to Draw up New Proposals for EU Workers

UK Immigration Taskforce to Draw up New Proposals for EU Workers

October 20, 2016 Education

An immigration taskforce in the UK is set to draw up a set of proposals that would reduce the number of people moving to the country to less than 100,000, with individuals likely to be required to find work before being able to get a visa. It would mean that citizens from European Union countries […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for British expats left worried after UK votes to leave the EU

British expats left worried after UK votes to leave the EU

June 24, 2016 Britain

Hundreds of thousands of British expats in the European Union are now wondering about their future after the UK voted to leave the political and economic community. Many had been angry that they were not allowed to vote in a referendum that will now prove to be historic as voting rules in the UK meant […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for European Union countries seeing number of freelances soar

European Union countries seeing number of freelances soar

June 15, 2016 European Union

There are more freelance workers in the European Union than ever before with new research showing their numbers have increased by 24% from 7.7 million to 9.6 million between 2008 and 2015. The figures by IPSE, the Association of Independent Professionals and the Self Employed, will be of interest to expats as they often end […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Leaving the EU could have an impact on foreign students, studies suggest

Leaving the EU could have an impact on foreign students, studies suggest

June 10, 2016 European Union

Leaving the European Union could make the UK a less attractive place for international students to study and could also lead to a brain drain with top graduates seeking work overseas, research suggests. First, a report from the Institute for Social and Economic Research (ISER) points out that students from EU countries are among the […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for Campaign for the UK to leave the EU wants to introduce a points based immigration system

Campaign for the UK to leave the EU wants to introduce a points based immigration system

June 3, 2016 European Union

A debate has opened up again in the UK over whether the country should adopt an Australian style immigration system based on points. It is an issue where, in the run up to the referendum on 23 June on the future of the UK in the European Union, many people are divided. Immigration is currently […]

Read the full article →
Thumbnail image for New analysis reveals significant impact on immigration if UK leaves EU

New analysis reveals significant impact on immigration if UK leaves EU

May 26, 2016 European Union

If the UK decides to leave the European Union there would be s significant reduction in immigration, according to a new research report. The analysis published by the National Institute of Economic Research (NIESR) shows that this reduction would lead, in the long run, to lower GDP per capita which in turn would necessitate higher […]

Read the full article →